Now that you know what you're looking for and where to find it, here's how to make your first catch: 1. Twilight Stormfish (night variant, found in any region) Shadow Stormfish (rarest, found in any region) Shores Stormfish (found in Shores of Plenty) Wreckers: Found near shipwrecks, use wormsīlackcloud Wrecker (found during storms at shipwrecks)Īncient Stormfish (found in Ancient Isles) Wildsplashes: Found in The Wilds, use earthwormsĪncientscales: Found in the Ancient Isles, use leechesĭevilfish: Found in Devil's Roar region, use grubsīattlegills: Found near active Skull Forts and Skeleton Ships, use grubs Plentifins: Found in the Shores of Plenty, use earthworms Raven Islehopper (rarest, found at Mermaid's Hideaway, Discovery Ridge, Shark Bait Cove, Wanderers Refuge)Īmethyst Islehopper (night variant, found at Smuggler's Bay, Mermaid's Hideaway, The Crooked Masts, Old Faithful Isle, Snake Island, Devil's Ridge) Honey Islehopper (found at Crescent Isle, Kraken's Fall, Sunken Grove, Plunder Valley, Discovery Ridge) Moss Islehopper (found at Lone Cove, Wanderer's Refuge, Marauder's Arch, Thieves' Haven) Stone Islehopper (found at Sailor's Bounty, Cannon Cove, Shipwreck Bay, Shark Bait Cove, Crook's Hollow)

Islehoppers: Found near islands, no bait needed Pondies: Found in island or fort ponds, no bait needed Splashtails: Found everywhere, no bait needed

Sea of thieves fish